|
| |
 |
| |
International IT Services Featured in Business Leader Magazine |
| |
Feature Story:
The Offshore Movement: Savior or Threat?
by Linda Carron Ray |
| |
Joe started the day early, having set his alarm clock (Made in Japan) for 6am. While his coffeepot (Made in Germany) was perking, he shaved with his electric razor (Made in Hong Kong). He put on his dress shirt (Made in Sri Lanka), his pants (Made in Singapore), and his shoes (Made in Indonesia). After cooking his breakfast in his new electric skillet (Made in India), he sat down with his pocket calculator (Made in China), to see how much he could spend today. After setting his Swiss watch to the radio (Made in China), he got in his Japanese made car and continued his search for a GOOD AMERICAN JOB!!! At the end of yet another discouraging and fruitless day, Joe decided to relax for a while. He put on his sandals (Made In Brazil), poured himself a glass of French wine, turned on his TV (Made in Korea), and wondered why he couldn't find a GOOD AMERICAN JOB!!! |
| |
It's not just the manufacturing jobs that are shipping out to foreign lands, information technology services, back room operations and call centers are increasingly finding workers in other nations.
Michael Le, CEO of Raleigh-based International IT Services, provides technology-consulting services for one-fifth the cost of most technical consulting firms. He can do this because his workers live in Vietnam. Meanwhile, in North Carolina, the unemployment rate continues to push the tiles off the ceiling.
Overseas developing nations are striving to bolster the quality of life for their citizens. In the U.S. sit the thousands of unemployed techies who once enjoyed very lucrative careers, but now must borrow against their homes and take low-paying service jobs. In between are corporate executives and boards of directors trying to please shareholders.
Some say that what NAFTA did for the textile and manufacturing industries, so global outsourcing is disassembling the technical teams of mounting numbers in the United States. Others welcome this new source of knowledge-base workers who fore see globalization ultimately become an integral part of the American economy, allowing domestic companies to concentrate on leadership driven enterprises.
"We do not take away U.S. jobs," explains Le. "In reality, and especially in this economic climate, we save U.S. jobs since the U.S. companies save so much money outsourcing their IT requirements. They can reallocate the money they save to retrain their IT employees so that they can keep them and best utilize their skill set."
Jeff K. Smith, business development manager for Software Development Europe, Inc., an American software design, development and testing company, also points out that these jobs are not being moved offshore for the purpose of reducing American jobs, but to break into other markets. "If a company already has a presence or they are trying to create awareness in another country, placing an employee base in that country helps boost business growth. This could allow the company to hire more American workers," Smith explains.
Forrester Research, a Cambridge, Mass., consulting firm that identifies and analyzes emerging trends in technology and their impact on business, reports that nearly one million IT-related jobs will move offshore over the course of the next 15 years. General Electric, IBM, Motorola and Microsoft have all opened research centers in China recently. Intel's Pentium 4 chips are assembled and Dell Computers are built there. DuPont, Emerson Electric and dozens of other Fortune 500 companies have also moved production to China.
Corporations are moving jobs overseas because they can get more bang for their buck. And the local IT workers who have been deleted - mainly entry to mid-level programmers - must reinvent their skill set. |
| |
COMPETITIVE EVOLUTION
Responsibility to correct the imbalance rests with both employers and employees; say those involved in the debate. Corporations have a responsibility to the community from which they've flourished and employees bear the responsibility of upgrading their skills and talents to make themselves worth the higher wages.
Craig Butler, an account executive in DBM's Raleigh office, says that in today's tight global job market, hiring executives are looking for employees who are nothing less than a perfect fit. And they are willing to go through lengthy hiring processes to get that perfect candidate. DBM, a provider of strategic human resource solutions, helps organizations align their workforces to meet changing business needs. Butler says he sees first hand what global competition is creating in the workforce.
"Employees must continually enhance their skills to remain competitive," Butler says. "And the resume and cover letter must be flawless." Leadership and management skills are becoming more in demand as front line people are hired in other countries. People who can manage offshore projects also are more in demand.
Butler emphasizes, "Just as the American manufacturer had to evolve, so must the IT people stay ahead of their game through education and certification."
Smith agrees. He says, "Many of the IT jobs moving over seas are the tedious, less exciting positions that many Americans would rather not to do.'
On the other hand, there are pitfalls to offshore outsourcing, says Butler. "More often, we see huge cultural differences that can be difficult to surmount," he says. "Other managers in other countries may not possess the same sense of urgency when issues arise, and it is often more difficult to impart that importance when a CEO is not onsite - or even in the same country. Many companies are trying it out and canceling their offshore partnerships because of that."
But whether a company decides to downsize locally to decrease costs, or bring in management from overseas headquarters, it is all the more important for management to maintain impeccable communications with American employees, Butler adds. "When people understand why a certain skill set was brought over, or even why certain jobs are being outsourced, it is easier for them to buy-in to the idea," he says. |
| |
SHIFTING LOYALTIES
Mark Finkelstein, an attorney with Raleigh-based Herring McBennett Mills & Finkelstein, PLLC, says he brings a unique perspective to the debate of corporate profits over corporate America's responsibility to its workers. "I'm one of the very few people I know who has worked on both sides of this issue that has polarized employers and employees for years," he says. "I've represented everyone from a plant that was closing and shipping its jobs overseas to a Siek man who was terminated by a health care organization because he refused to shave his beard."
Finkelstein provides administrative and civil litigation services and business and employment law advice, including litigation involving unfair trade practices, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, breach of contract, employment law, environmental claims, negligence and trade secret protection. He says there are three perspectives to the globalization issue.
"Traditionally, the board of directors runs a company and their obligation is to maximize their value," he says. "If they can make more profits by offshoring, they have an obligation to do so. This very much follows the fair market model."
He says that government changes those obligations when a company becomes insolvent. "The obligation then switches from shareholders to creditors." And the government protects displaced workers with laws that offer protections such as the WARN Act, which requires plants to give a notice of its closing and provide retraining funds.
Finally, the non-shareholding low wage consumers - most of us - benefit from the shifts to offshore workers. "For example, the average parent wants to buy a talking Elmo for his kid," Finkelstein says. "At one time, this may have been made by U. S. workers earning higher wages and cost the parent $6. Now he can buy it made in China for $2."
Finkelstein says the key to a balanced economy of scale is for corporate decision makers to decide where the best quality for the best price can be achieved. And with America continuing to set the standards of quality, the higher paying design jobs will remain in the U.S., which makes the importance of our school systems ever more urgent.
"We need to keep reinventing ourselves," he suggests. "As a society, our responsibility is to support local education. The way to keep jobs in the U.S. is to make sure U.S. workers remain the most competitive and best educated on the planet, so that companies are paying higher wages and getting higher value."
In addition, maintaining a higher paid workforce also creates greater consumer spending, which supports corporate profits. "Having workers with higher incomes is more important to American companies than they may realize," Finkelstein says.
While sending his work overseas to his Vietnamese homeland, Le contends that he also is contributing to the American economy by maintaining a U.S. corporate headquarters in Raleigh. "We pay the taxes here," he says. "That is one way we differentiate ourselves from foreign headquartered companies."
Meanwhile, the wagons of controversy are turning with organizations such as Tradealert.com, a web-based watchdog group sponsored by the U. S. Business and Industry Council. Tradealert publishes names of corporations who send work overseas. The group also recommends actions that can influence more fair trade policies. The list includes running for office on a pro-American jobs platform, contacting elected officials, writing editorials and sending money to groups such as their own. |
| |
ON THE HOMEFRONT
In North Carolina, Governor Easley's Economic Development Board reports that with 135,000 job losses in 2000-02 and the fourth-highest unemployment rate in the nation at 6.3% in August 2002, North Carolina needs to get its residents back to work in good jobs that boost their income. Indeed, say Department of Commerce officials, recruitment, and not researching where the lost jobs are going to, is the number one mandate on Jones Street. Thus, numbers of how many NC jobs have been lost to overseas workers is unavailable from the state.
As one of the nation's leading technology states, North Carolina is home to 4,000 information technology firms and 230 biotechnology, contract research and pharmaceutical companies. To support the growth of these industries the Economic Development Board has adopted a strategy which includes targeting resources to support these key areas of enterprise and make investments that will enhance its competitiveness with funding geared toward new research from the universities, well-trained workers from community colleges, and location opportunities in research parks. By allocating resources and making investments in initiatives such as high-skilled workforce training programs, expanded research programs, super-computing facilities and industry-focused institutions, North Carolina can cultivate a better business climate for new economy companies.
North Carolina should develop strategies, the board reports, to educate public leaders about the ever-changing world of science and technology. Additionally, the state and private sector should provide local leaders with current information on the infrastructure and support requirements of new economy companies - companies like IITS and other global economic industries. "It can be good for everyone," says Le. |
| |
| Good Morning Vietnam |
Good Bye Jobs |
Michael Le and others believe that in the coming years, Vietnam will become one of the United States' strongest commercial allies. Currently, India is the largest provider of offshore IT services, with the market estimated to be worth $6.3 billion in 2000-2001. Software development activity in Vietnam has recently enjoyed a surge in interest and activity, thanks in large part to the support and dedication of the country's government. In May 2000, the government affirmed its commitment to the rapidly growing software industry, establishing goals of training 50,000 IT workers by 2004 and expanding software technology parks and zones. The government also set a target of $500 million in software exports by 2005. Why Vietnam?
- Vietnam possesses tremendous human resources with almost 75% of the population younger than 35.
- Low-level tasks such as coding and software testing can be performed in less-developed countries at costs as low as ten percent of domestic ones
- Vietnam's government is aggressively pursuing the growth of its software development industry with significant tax credits for employees, employers, investors and even computer science and engineering students
- 98% literacy rate
- The government continues to establish incentives and structures to pursue its goal of becoming the second largest provider of outsourced software development in the world.
|
While company closings and layoffs are a matter of public record, the reasons for those reductions in force are mainly dependent on self-reporting. And with the vast numbers of jobs reportedly moving offshore, it is difficult to believe the following numbers. Thanks to the Research Triangle Regional Partnership, numbers of closings and layoffs are available. But political concerns obviously shade the reasons for the vast numbers of job losses in the 13 county region covered by the organization. Most of the companies who either closed their North Carolina operations or laid off workers say they did so due to "restructuring, reorganization, and financial concerns." Thus, little documentation exists as to the direct effect of offshore outsourcing in the region and the state.
Year: 2000
Reported closings: 127, affecting 3,627 people
Reported layoffs: 45, affecting 3,486 people
Outsourcing given as reason for downsizing: 2
Year: 2001
Reported closings: 189, affecting 7,001 people
Reported layoffs: 153, affecting 11,536 people
Outsourcing given as reason for downsizing: 0
Year: 2002 (first six months)
Reported closings: 109, affecting 5,465 people
Reported layoffs: 84, affecting 4,210 people
Outsourcing given as reason for downsizing: 0
|
|
| |
| Trade Adjustment Assistance Program |
| The Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) program is a federal program established in 1974 under the Trade Act of 1974, and amended in 2002. Its purpose is to provide assistance to workers who lose their jobs or whose hours of work and wages are reduced as a result of increased imports.
To be eligible for assistance from the TAA program, a Petition for Trade Adjustment Assistance must be filed by a group of three or more of the affected workers, a company (the employer) official, a union, or other duly authorized representative. This Petition is sent to the US Department of Labor and the Trade Adjustment Assistance office of the North Carolina Employment Security Commission.
The Petition will set forth information that supports the Petitioners position that the layoff or reduced work hours and wages were caused by import competition from off shore companies. In order for the US Department of Labor to issue a Certification for worker eligibility to apply for TAA services and benefits, the following specific requirements must be met:
- Workers been laid off or put on a reduced schedule (worker put on 80% or less reduced work and wages)
- Sales or productions of the affected company have declined
- Increased imports have contributed significantly to worker layoffs
The Petition for TAA process typically takes an average of 40 days (this is period from the Petition being filed, to a determination by the US Department of Labor to certify or deny the workers eligibility to apply for TAA services and benefits.
Based on individual eligibility, a worker who is a member of a certified worker group may receive one or more of the following services and benefits:
Reemployment Services
Employment counseling; Assessment; Job development and placement; Support services
Job Search Allowances
For cost of a job search outside of the local area
Trade Readjustment Allowances
Up to 104 weeks of cash payments for eligible workers enrolled in full-time training
Transportation and Subsistence Allowances
For cost of attending training outside the local area
Health Insurance Coverage Assistance
Tax credits covering up to 65%of the monthly health insurance premium paid by the worker
Training Services
Classroom training (occupational skills training); On-the-job training; Employer-based training; Basic skills or remedial education (includes literacy training and English as a Second Language)
The typical application process for Trade Adjustment Assistance:
- Workers hours and wages are reduced or workers are laid off.
- Workers are made aware of programs and services available to them at their local JobLink Career Center or other workforce development service location in the communities in North Carolina.
- A Petition (see above) is filed to the US Department of Labor for worker certification for TAA eligibility.
- After investigating the Petition (average 40 days), The US Department of Labor certifies or denies eligibility of the affected worker group to apply for TAA services and benefits.
- Certified workers apply individually for services at JobLink Career Centers around the state or at local Employment Security Commission offices.
- There is an appeals process for workers whose Petition for certification was denied by the US Department of Labor.
For more information contact the JobLink Career Center at NC Department of Commerce - Commission on Workforce Development by calling (919) 715-3300 or log on to www.joblink.state.nc.us . |
|
| |
Linda Carron Ray is a freelance writer based in Raleigh, NC.
Engage us with your comments. Send email to: editor@businessleader.com . |
 |
|
| |
|
|